Strategic Board Recruitment: A Comprehensive Guide

By Bonnie Hilory

Introduction 

Effective board recruitment is essential for nonprofit sustainability and governance. This guide provides a structured approach to finding and onboarding board members who bring value, diversity, and commitment to your organization. 

The Board Recruitment Philosophy 

Mantra: Board manages the Board (and hires the CEO/Executive Director). 

A successful board recruitment process balances organizational needs with efficient use of staff and board time. The board should take primary ownership of the recruitment process, with appropriate staff support.  

Creating Compelling Position Descriptions 

An informative board position description should include: 

Time Commitment:  

• Specific range of hours per month/quarter 

• Meeting frequency and duration 

• Committee participation expectations 

• Special event attendance requirements 

  Meeting Information:  

• Standard meeting times, dates, and locations 

• Virtual or in-person format 

• Attendance policies 

  Organizational Context:  

• Link to agency website with mission and vision 

• Current board composition with member bios 

• Strategic priorities and challenges 

  Contribution Expectations:  

• Financial giving expectations (aim for 100% board giving) 

• Fundraising responsibilities 

• Ambassador/influencer roles 

Evaluating Board Candidates 

The Four W's 

• Wealth: Financial capacity or fundraising connections 

• Work: Professional skills and experience 

• Wisdom: Knowledge, expertise, and judgment 

• Wallop: Influence, networks, and community standing 

The Three T's 

• Time: Availability for meetings, events, and preparation 

• Talent: Skills, expertise, and professional background 

• Treasure: Financial contributions and fundraising capabilities 

Streamlining the Recruitment Workflow 

1. Needs Assessment:  

• Conduct annual board composition analysis 

• Identify gaps in skills, demographics, and experience 

• Prioritize recruitment needs based on strategic plan 

2. Prospect Identification

• Create a prospect pipeline committee 

• Leverage existing board networks 

• Engage community partners for recommendations 
  a

3. Cultivation Process:

• Initial informational meetings with board chair/CEO 

• Invitation to observe board meeting or program 

• Share organizational materials and success stories 

4. Vetting and Selection  

• Formal application process (submitting a cover letter and resume is fine) 

• Structured interviews with nominating committee 

• Reference checks and background review 

5. Onboarding

• Comprehensive orientation process 

• Mentorship with experienced board member 

• Early engagement in meaningful work 

Staff Support for Board Recruitment 

• Appropriate Staff Roles:  

• Maintain board recruitment materials 

• Coordinate meeting logistics 

• Track prospects and follow-up 

• Provide data and organizational context 

• Staff/Board Boundaries:  

• Staff supports but doesn't lead the process  

• Helps market board vacancy opportunities on website, social media, and volunteer recruitment channels such as Volunteer Match 

• Conducts initial vetting of board candidates to confirm alignment with organizational needs:  

• Time: discusses board meeting schedule and committee work expectations 

• Financial: clarifies expectation that each board member contributes annually (often overlooked but critical to address early) 

• Awareness: explains expectation that board members serve as organizational ambassadors 

• Executive Director provides input on needs  

• Typically aligned with the strategic plan 

• Staff prepares materials but board makes decisions  

• Board member job description 

• Bylaws with committee structure 

• Most recent 990 form 

• Current strategic plan (if available) 

• Program materials, brochures, annual report, or impact report 

• Staff receives candidate resume or LinkedIn profile and statement of interest after initial meeting with Executive Director  

• After receiving these materials, the candidate is forwarded to the appropriate board entity:  

• May be a nominations committee or executive committee delegated to meet with candidates 

Building Board Diversity 

• Diversity Dimensions:  

• Demographic (race, ethnicity, gender, age) 

• Professional backgrounds and expertise 

• Community connections and lived experiences 

• Thinking styles and perspectives 

• Inclusive Recruitment Strategies:  

• Expand recruitment networks beyond current board connections 

• Partner with community organizations serving diverse populations 

• Review recruitment materials for inclusive language 

• Create welcoming onboarding experiences 

• Evaluation Metrics:  

• Track diversity metrics over time 

• Assess board culture and inclusion 

• Measure progress against diversity goals 

Key Interview Questions (used by board members during their meet and greet or interview) 

Consider these questions when meeting with board prospects: 

1. "What aspects of our mission resonate most with you personally?" 

2. "How do you see yourself contributing to our organization's goals?" 

3. "What experiences have prepared you for board service?" 

4. “ Have you ever served on a nonprofit board before?”  

5. “What have you learned from previous board service or volunteer experiences?" 

6. "What concerns or questions do you have about joining our board?" 

7. "How would serving on our board align with your personal and professional goals?" 

8. "What other commitments might compete for your time and attention?" 

9. "How comfortable are you with fundraising and financial oversight responsibilities?" 

10. “How familiar are you with social media and is so what platforms are you comfortable using?” 

11. “Do they have any known conflict of interests?” 

Resources for Board Recruitment 

• BoardSource: https://boardsource.org/fundamental-topics-of-nonprofit-board-service/composition-recruitment/board-recruitment/ Comprehensive resources on board composition and recruitment best practices 

• Propel Nonprofits: Board Matrix https://www.propelnonprofits.org/resources/board-profile-worksheet/ Tool for assessing current board composition and identifying gaps 

• Bloomerang: "4 Sneaky-Good Questions to Ask Prospective Board Members" https://bloomerang.co/blog/4-sneaky-good-questions-to-ask-prospective-board-members Insightful interview questions for effective candidate evaluation 

• Blue Avocado: "Recruiting for Board Diversity" https://blueavocado.org/board-of-directors/recruiting-for-board-diversity-part-3-in-diversity-series/ Strategies for building diverse and inclusive boards 

• BoardEffect: "Board Recruitment and Onboarding Best Practices" https://www.boardeffect.com/blog/board-recruitment-onboarding-best-practices/ Guidance on streamlining the recruitment and onboarding process 

• National Council of Nonprofits: "Finding the Right Board Members" https://www.councilofnonprofits.org/tools-resources/finding-the-right-board-members-your-nonprofit Tips for identifying and recruiting qualified board candidates 

Contributed by Bonnie Hilory, Nonprofit Accelerator Principal/Founder.